We are Here to Serve You

Our team works together to provide the most thorough, accurate, and conveniently-delivered title products and settlement services that our clients need to move forward. We are committed to the ongoing improvement of our company, and we strive to create a culture of reliability, integrity, quality, and client care. We are a client-oriented agency, and we continue to work with the same communities that made us successful in the first place.

Feel free to call us at 866-601-8449 to speak to one of our leadership team members today!

Scott Stevenson, Esq.
CEO/Principal

Scott sets the vision and helps leads the direction of the company in his role as CEO.  He is a licensed attorney and title agent, and is a very active speaker and educator for the real estate industry. Scott is a Past-President of both the Ohio Land Title Association and the Central Ohio Land Title Association, and is very active in local, state, and national industry groups.  He is a 1995 graduate of Capital Law School and continues to practice law, regularly assisting real estate investors with their 1031 Exchanges.

Jonathan Holfinger, Esq.
COO/Principal 

Jonathan is a licensed attorney and title insurance agent in multiple states, and was the owner of Arrow Title Agency prior to its merger with Northwest Title in 2013. Jonathan oversees the general operations of the company, working closely with escrow and administrative staff. Jonathan's role encompasses many things, but you might find him teaching classes for realtors, solving closing problems, or providing counsel on real estate contracts. He is a 2002 graduate of The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law.

Karen Kitchen
Senior VP, Escrow

Karen manages our Escrow Branch Managers and helps assure that our day-to-day escrow operations run smoothly. She helps with strategic planning, management of our staff, oversight of our escrow banking practices, and she also assists in all aspects of customer service, including conducting closings. Karen previously was Chairperson of Northwest Select Title Agency, LLC, prior to being promoted into her current role in 2013.

Teresa Geiger
Senior VP, Title

With over twenty years in the title insurance industry, Teresa leads our Title Department with her underwriting expertise. She has served as a licensed Ohio title insurance agent since 2007, and possesses a wide spectrum of experience in our industry which includes in-depth transactional expertise; title underwriting; remittance reporting; and production management. Teresa was named as Arrow Title Agency’s 2012 “Employee of the Year”, and was the 2013 “Manager of the Year”, as part of the Northwest Title Family of Companies.

Sarah Bost
Senior VP, Sales and Marketing

Sarah leads, manages and assists our sales staff and marketing department.  She is involved on a daily basis leading our sales efforts, attending association events, creating marketing initiatives, and getting Northwest involved in the community. She loves meeting people through different associations, events and closings while growing the business.  Sarah was Arrow Title Agency's 2012 "Salesperson of the Year" and 2013 "Employee of the Year" as part of the Northwest Title Family of Companies.